All-Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC)

2000: Ken Elder^ (1st), Adam Williams (1st), Justin Secrist (1st), T.J. Coder (1st), Mario Matesic (HM), Ryan Stevens (HM) 
2001: Mario Matesic (1st), Justin Secrist (1st), Ken Elder (1st), T.J. Coder (1st), Carl Bosack (1st), Tony Bierly (HM)
2002: Justin Secrist (1st), Matt Steinbugl (HM)
2003: Josh Wolf^, Luke Diehl (1st), Jeff Thompson (HM)
2004: Dennis McKimm (1st), Jeff Thompson (1st), Shaun Greenland (1st), Andy Clouse (2nd), Jake Hargreaves (2nd)
2005: Tony Petulla* (1st), Kyle Wright (2nd), Jake Hargreaves (HM), Andy Bagley (HM), Chris Scelsi (HM)
2006: Tony Petulla* (1st), Chris Scelsi (1st), Andy Bagley (2nd), Jeremy Vogel (HM)
2007: Tyler Weyant (2nd), Jeremy Vogel (HM)
2008: Tony Petulla (1st), Paul Keith (2nd), Grady Luzier (HM)
2009: Cord Heine^ (1st), Grady Luzier (1st), Paul Keith (2nd), Jimmy Baum (HM)
2010: Jimmy Baum (1st), Chris Keeler (2nd), Tyler Stiffler (3rd), Cord Heine (3rd), Jim Byers (3rd)
2011: Trevor Conner% (1st), Grady Luzier (1st), John Schall (1st), Jimmy Baum (1st)
2012: Cord Heine (1st), Jimmy Baum (1st)
2013: Ken Terpack (1st)
2014: Pat McHenry^ (1st), Logan Madill (2nd), Jordan Swope (2nd), Jeff Deveney (3rd)
2015: Pat McHenry (3rd), Jack Cleary (3rd)
2016: Jim Shomberg (1st), Gavin Roselli (2nd)
2017: Hunter Breon^ (2nd), Peter Jacobs (3rd)
2018: Jim Shomberg (1st), Peter Jacobs (1st), Catcher Cumming (2nd), Tyler Manger (3rd), Austin Anderson (3rd), Hunter Breon (3rd)
2019: George Stiuso (1st), Chase Clouser (2nd), Catcher Cumming (3rd)
2021: Catcher Cumming* (1st), Jake Hillard^ (1st), Jared Ennis (2nd), Kyle Glass (3rd)
2022: Richard Carey (1st), Jake Hillard (2nd), Garrett Alauzen (3rd)

2023: Mack Meengs (2nd), Tyreke Green (2nd), Jake Hillard (2nd), Alex Kitko (3rd), Timothy Richard (3rd), Corey Chamberlain (3rd), Garrett Alauzen (3rd)

* denotes AMCC Player of the Year; ^ denotes AMCC Newcomer of the Year; % denotes AMCC Pitcher of the Year

Coach of the Year awards

2000: Joe Piotti - AMCC

All-Eastern College Athletic Conference (ECAC) Division III

2010 (South Region): Jimmy Baum (2nd)
2011 (South Region): Grady Luzier (2nd), Cord Heine (2nd)
2014 (South Region): Pat McHenry (1st)
2016 (South Region): Jim Shomberg (1st)
2017 (South Region): Hunter Breon^
2019 (All-ECAC): Chase Clouser (HM), George Stiuso (HM)

^ denotes ECAC Rookie of the Year

American Baseball Coaches Association (ABCA)/Rawlings All-Region

2011 (Mid-Atlantic): John Schall (2nd)
2014 (Mideast): Pat McHenry (1st)
2016 (Mideast): Jim Shomberg (3rd)
2018 (Mideast): Jim Shomberg (3rd)
2021 (Mideast): Catcher Cumming (3rd), Jake Hillard (3rd)

D3baseball.com All-Region

2016 (Mideast): Jim Shomberg (2nd)
2021 (Mideast): Jake Hillard (2nd)

2023 (Region 7): Tyreke Green (3rd)

D3baseball.com Preseason All-American

2017: Jim Shomberg (HM)

CoSIDA Academic All-District

2021: Catcher Cumming (1st)

CSC Academic All-District

2023: Timothy Richard, Alex Hlivia, Garrett Alauzen, Mack Meengs