All-Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC)

2001: Jared Bucher (1st), Andrew Nichols (2nd), Mitch Fletcher (2nd)

2002: Jared Bucher (1st), Kamah Duwana (1st), Andrew Nichols (1st), Ryan Meyers (2nd), Mitch Fletcher (2nd), Andrew Zechman (HM)

2003: David Garcia^ (1st), Paul Miller (1st), Andrew Zechman (1st), Ryan Zechman (2nd), Ryan Meyers (2nd), Mitch Fletcher (2nd), Kurtis Wagner (2nd), Joe Capen (HM)

2004: Bryan Pierzga^ (1st), Tim Wassell (1st), Andrew Zechman (2nd), Chris Cowman (2nd), Ryan Zechman (HM), JC Campbell (HM), Evan Spence (HM)

2005: Bryan Pierzga (1st), Tim Wassell (1st), Conor Nelson (2nd), Evan Spence (2nd), Brock Heller (2nd), Andrew Zechman (2nd), Chris Cowman (HM)

2006: Bryan Pierzga (1st), Dan Saxton (1st), Corey Suter (2nd), Josh Guthridge (2nd), Tim Morris (2nd), Brock Heller (HM)

2007: Bryan Pierzga* (1st), Dan Saxton (1st), JC Campbell (2nd), Brock Heller (HM), Len Castor (HM)

2008: Tim Morris (2nd), Will Gray (2nd), Geremy Graham (HM), Nick Giffen (HM), Rich Hopewell (HM)

2009: Joe DeSteffano (1st), Nicholas Kline^ (2nd), Dane Kelsey (3rd), Chris Bolea (3rd)

2010: Sam Aumiller (1st), Nathan Sonnenthal (2nd), Mike Sheridan (2nd), Alex Wilson (3rd), Dan Kennedy (3rd)

2011: Sam Aumiller (1st), Brandon Arvey (2nd), Mike Robinson (2nd), Justin Su Kwak (2nd), Garrett Storm (3rd)

2012: Dylan Pickering (2nd), Mike Robinson (3rd), Quinn Oyler (3rd), Garrett Storm (3rd), Brandon Moss (3rd)

2013: Dan Kennedy (1st), Karl Stephan (2nd), Trent Landis (3rd), Garrett Storm (3rd)

2014: Trent Landis (2nd), Seth Murrelle (3rd)

2015: Jordan Crist (3rd), Eric Alesius (3rd)

2016: Matthew Hibbs (1st), Seth Murrelle (2nd), Jacob Weaver (2nd), Jordan Crist (3rd), Eric Alesius (3rd)

2017: Seth Murrelle (3rd)

2018: Jordan Crist (2nd)

2019: --

2020: (no awards given)

2021: Grady Ballard (2nd), Ciaran Corr (3rd)

2022: Henry Couchara (3rd)

* denotes AMCC Player of the Year; ^ denotes AMCC Newcomer of the Year

Coach of the Year Awards

2001: John Parente – AMCC

2004: John Parente – AMCC

2010: Patrick Taylor – AMCC

All-Eastern College Athletic Conference (ECAC) Division III

2011 (South Region): Sam Aumiller (2nd)

National Soccer Coaches Association of America (NSCAA) DIII All-Region selections

2002: Jared Bucher (3rd)

2003: David Garcia (2nd)

2004: Tim Wassell (3rd)

2005: Bryan Pierzga (3rd), Tim Wassell (3rd)

2006: Bryan Pierzga (1st)

2007: Bryan Pierzga (3rd)

2009: Joe DeSteffano (3rd)

NSCAA Regional Academic All-American

2005: Tim Wassell (3rd)

CSC Academic All-District

2022: Garrett Giedroc