All-Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC)

2015: Brandon Stitt (1st), Matt Huey (2nd), Jacob Byers (2nd)

2016: Matt Huey* (1st), Billy Smith (2nd), Brandon Stitt (2nd)

2017: Bradley Colditz (1st), Brandon Arentz^ (1st), Wally Rivera-Berrios (1st), Daniel Downs (2nd), Jacob Byers (2nd)

2018: Daniel Downs (1st), Justin Bannister (1st), Tommy Kisick (1st), Brandon Arentz (1st)

2019: Brian Sheddy (2nd), Daniel Downs (2nd)

2020: Ben Beaver (1st), Frank Perehinec (2nd)

2021: Philip Silva (2nd), Jared Bodisch (2nd)

2022: Philip Silva (1st), Connor Baker (2nd), Jared Bodisch (2nd), Micah Brinker (2nd)

2023: Avery Farabaugh (3rd), Jared Kish (3rd), Connor Ebersole (3rd)

* denotes AMCC Player of the Year; ^ denotes AMCC Newcomer of the Year

All-North Eastern Athletic Conference (NEAC)

2015: Matt Huey (1st), Jacob Byers (2nd), Brandon Stitt% (3rd), Zack Graham (3rd)

2016: Matt Huey* (1st), Billy Smith (2nd), Bradley Colditz (3rd), Brandon Stitt (3rd)

2017: Bradley Colditz* (1st), Wally Rivera-Berrios% (1st), Brandon Arentz (2nd), Daniel Downs (2nd)

2018: Daniel Downs (1st), Justin Bannister (2nd), Brandon Arentz (2nd), Tommy Kisick (3rd)

* denotes NEAC Player of the Year; % denotes NEAC Defensive Player of the Year

Coach of the Year awards

2017: Phil Peterman – AMCC

2018: Phil Peterman – AMCC

All-Eastern College Athletic Conference (ECAC) Division III

2016 (All-ECAC): Matt Huey (2nd)

2017 (South Region): Wally Rivera-Berrios% (1st)

% denotes ECAC DIII Regional Defensive Player of the Year

NCAA Division III Statistical Champions

2014: Brandon Stitt (Digs Per Set: 3.34)

2015: Brandon Stitt (Digs Per Set: 3.89)

2017: Wally Rivera-Berrios (Digs Per Set: 4.25)